Recently, I went to the gyno and listened to my first “weight talk.” Fun. What I find most apalling is that I didn’t realize how ironic all this was until a couple of months after this appointment…
When I was a normal weight (or thin depending on the eye of the beholder), my doctors were very happy with my condition. Never mind that I was falling apart. I was painfully cold all the time. I couldn’t think my way out of a paper bag, due to the malnutrition due to extreme restriction. Almost any food or drink consumption caused painful indigestion. For some reason, I was constantly in the bathroom cuz even just a little liquid in my bladder caused a feeling or urgently needing to pee. I had migraines three or four times a week on average. My lips turned blue during my workouts. My complection was often grayish. I couldn’t help but binge on a regular basis from all the restriction. My hair was thinning. A paper cut would take weeks to heal. Walking to school in even a sprinkle of a rainshower WITH an umbrella almost always caused me to catch a cold. Colds almost always turned into bronchitis. Bronchitis generally lasted six months each bout. My asthma symptoms were often painful and I used my inhaler several times a day.
The only concern I remember any doctor voicing was about the copious amount of caffeine that I drank. No one cared about the restriction or the sypmtoms that went with it. Perhaps they just thought I was sickly… if so, they were naive.
I got treatment for my eating disorder and my weight has gone up and down depending on what anti-depressant I’m on. The one I’m on right now caused me to gain about three dress sizes…. and now the doctors wanna talk to me about weight loss. I wanna smack these doctors in the face with a shovel. I am HEALTHIER than ever… but of course that doesn’t matter, cuz I’m fat. Wha…?
My asthma hardly ever makes a peep. I don’t even catch all the colds that my husband catches and walking outside in wet weather no longer causes the default cold or flu. As people go, I’m still pretty cold blooded, but I’m no longer painfully cold all the time. Doctors keep mentioning that my weight must be causing horrible blood pressure problems for me. Yeah… then they check my bp and find that my bp is LOW. My bp is low AND I take ritalin… a med that increases blood pressure. Yeah, my weight is really sending my bp sky high! Everyone get your helmets – I could explode any minute from this extremely high blood pressure!
My stomach no longer gives me all the trouble it used to. I still have a sensitive tummy, but I no longer dread eating or drinking anything for fear of some nasty indigestion that could potentially last for hours. I no longer have daily acid reflux. My hair is beautiful again. Maybe some of the thinning is permanent, but whatever. I’m not about to beat myself up for spilled milk that I have worked very hard to mop up over the years. I seem to have been one of the lucky ones who got some of their hair fullness back after years of restriction though. My complexion looks healthy today. No more gray. Paper cuts heal so much faster now. I’m no longer covered in mystery bruises. I haven’t had bronchitis in a few years now. Whooo hoooo! Migraines are now rare for me.
But, now, all of a sudden, I’m getting all these health lectures when I’m healthier than ever… and when I was starving myself and at a normal weight, I felt like I was constantly screaming for attention to my numerous health issues and still doctors ignored me, because I LOOKED healthy (to them) merely because I was thin. Everyone knows that thin equals healthy, right? 😛
I suspect my weight is about to go back down again due to changes in the anti-depressant that caused my weight to go up. My feelings about all this is mixed. I’m not sure whether to be pissed for being (potentially anyway) treated differently and escaping the fat = unhealthy rhetoric or relieved not to hear that ignorant stuff anymore from ignorant doctors when I feel vulnerable enough wearing paper clothes and maybe even having my lady parts poked at with ouchy instruments. Meh.
The anti-depressant that caused my weight gain worked well in helping my depression for quite some time. Even as it made me fat, I didn’t care. I was HAPPY! My psychiatrist seemed to not understand how I could go from “normal” to fat and actually get happier. He offered to change my meds simply to help me lose weight. For those of you who have never been on psych meds, I will explain what a ridiculous offer he made. Changing psych meds is a big deal. It can takes weeks, months or even years to find a med that works and doesn’t cause horrible side effects for you once you and your doc decide a med change is in order. Changing anti-depressants is not like changing from Advil to Tylenol for your headaches. Changing psych meds can be a long and painful journey. If you work full-time, it can be even more difficult, because changing meds (even changing onto a med that works really well for you) can cause weeks of symptoms in getting used to the new med and withdrawling frmo the old meds. For me, this generally means nausea, migraines, a short fuse, forgetfulness and being very easily flustered for at least two weeks. It is no freakin’ joke…. and I’m supposed to volunteer for this merely because an otherwise lovely anti-depressant made me fat???!!! ARE YOU KIDDING ME???? I made it clear to my psychiatrist that I’d far rather be fat and happy than be a normal weight and depressed or going through unnecessary psych med change difficulties.
The rebellious part of me would like to stay fat (even though I’ve quit the med that caused my fatness because it stopped working for me) just to make my psychiatrist uncomfortable and to avoid the “you’ve lost weight! how did you do it!?!” talk from my co-workers. But, that misses the whole body and size acceptance point. I believe in letting my body be what it wants to be…. and so, I will… whether that means weight changes or not. Whatevs. I’d rather be fat and happy and sane and healthy… or whatever size my body naturally is and happy/healthy/sane. To my pdoc’s chagrin, I won’t be chucking future potential meds either if they make me fat or fatter. Maybe I can teach him a thing or two myself. He does seem to be fairly receptive…
If and when your doctors get ignorant on you, I hope you remember that you’re not alone and just cuz a doc is a doc doesn’t mean that they are always right. Hang in there, friends. I’m rooting you on… as I hope you root me on in my own journey.
–AngryGrayRainbows
omg GOOD FOR YOU and your self-awareness..!! !!
I had your situation in reverse…I see a psychologist, and my physician, together with feedback from the shrink and me, prescribes my brain-chemistry medicines for me. (Lexapro and a very small dose of klonopin)
About a year ago, like you hear people do, I tried to stop taking the meds…because I thought they might be related to weight-gain, and that was really getting me down at the time. It got worse. I became suicidal. When I went to see the physician, I told her what was up, and she begged me to go back on the meds…she said she was more concerned with getting my moods under control than me trying to slim down. (god bless this woman.) Still, she said, it was ultimately up to me.
While I considered her talk with me, I went straight home and watched the movie SYLVIA, about the life of Sylvia Plath…I identified with SP all the way through the movie. When it got to the scene where Sylvia commits suicide, and I actually felt happy for her, well, screw that! I knew I had to start taking the pills again. *haha!* And I did feel better.
It is so challenging to find physicians, headshrinks, trainers, counsellors, etc. who can all get on the same page with you re: weight, eating disorders, and brain chemistry issues…
SING IT!
I’ve just been through a doctor saga myself. He told me very pointedly that at my size I could collapse with a cardiac arrest at any moment. That made me feel great. And yes, like you AGR my bp is very healthy.
I got the weight talk from my gyno 2 years ago. After going up and down with weight, I was too embarassed to face her. But then I had a lump scare and went in. I was splayed out and not even 2 seconds into the exam she started pitching Weight Watchers to me. OMFG! WTF? That’s all she talked about during the time she was in my bizness …. Then she decided on a whim to get my thyroid checked. First time any doctor decided to do that, even though I have been a big girl all my life. Guess what? My thryoid sucks and is (in part) making me fat!
I’m rooting for you. 🙂 I love your blog and I think you’re fabulous.
Good lord but you sound like a sane and wonderful person. I just wanted to voice my support. Clearly your head is on straight, and, like all people who fit that description, your hard-won sanity is being challenged by people who can’t be bothered to educate themselves on what real life and real priorities are all about.
I don’t think I’ve commented here before, but I’ve been enjoying your posts for some time. I usually get here via the Fatosphere feed at Shapely Prose.
Do you think it would be helpful to adapt this into a letter for your gyno?
This is an AWESOME POST. It depresses me that doctors, people who are supposed to be medically TRAINED, think you’re fine because oyu look a certain way.
Oh boy this stuff makes me furious.
I’m so glad that you’re not taking that crap any more! And I wish that everyone could reach that place.
But you know what really struck me about this? The symptoms you describe when you were restricting sound like a living hell to me – and for the most part this is exactly what the doctors are selling people when they push bariatric surgery. I just cannot understand why they consider this to be healthier than being fat. Usually I pride myself on being able to see different points of view and at least understand how people get there, but this one, I just cannot fathom.
“I made it clear to my psychiatrist that I’d far rather be fat and happy than be a normal weight and depressed or going through unnecessary psych med change difficulties.”
Good for you! I find it appalling but all too believable that your psych wanted to change a drug that was working simply because it caused weight gain. Don’t these people learn about the stresses on body and mind that come with changing such potent medications? They damn well should; knowing how to taper a patient on and off of drugs is part of a psychiatrist’s basic skillset. (I know of what I speak, I’ve been seeing psychiatrists and psychologists for bipolar II and panic disorder for years.)
But of course, any amount of mental and physical distress is acceptable as long as it achieves the Holy Grail of weight loss. Arrrrgh! I hope your psychiatrist opens his mind and learns something from you about the relative values of sanity and weight.
Did you tell your doctor flat out that you were healthier and felt better than you did at a lower weight? It might open hir eyes.
Oh and I’m so glad that you are feeling better and doing so well. Your attitude is healthy and strong, and your body is doing well too. I’m sorry your med stopped working, that’s a pain too.
AGR, regarding rooting for you, I’m a friggin’ 1 woman cheerleading squad!
Go, Go AGR!
You can push that door ajar!
Fat or thin or inbetween
Ignore those doctors who are mean
You inspire all around
Plus or minus any pound
Go AGR, Hurray!
(shaking pompoms and jumping up and down!) (wearing a sports bra)
I wrote this letter to my doctor. I’ll edit out the names for both my privacy and that of Ms. Fat-Hater M.D. I have yet to send the letter – I was trying for ‘polite’, but it ended up being more like ‘barely controlled anger and strong disgust’. You can use portions of it, if you like.
Tell me what you think!
Dear Dr. __________,
I’m Audrey _________, a patient of yours. I am, according to the widely distributed weight charts, obese. I came to your office because it was important to me to be a healthy person regardless of my size, and I have questions about the importance of this to you.
I am aware that being fat is a contributing factor to some diseases, but my weight is not why I came here. I came here for an annual Pap exam, and to discuss a couple reproductive health issues. During my last visit, you not only commented on my weight, but pressed the issue.
You may believe that it is your duty, as a doctor, to encourage me to lose weight. I believe that as a Gynecologist, unless I have a reproductive problem that can be affected by my weight (I do not), that my weight should not be your concern. I am well aware of the existence of diets, food journals, “lifestyle changes”, and the like. I have tried many activities and programs suggested by doctors, and none of them have had the desired effect. I have been on many diets, and those, too, have failed. I have done much research on this issue and have decided that weight loss is a cosmetic concern, not a health problem.
I exercise regularly and eat a balanced diet; in fact, most of the food that I eat is organic/natural. There are many reasons that fat people may be viewed as unhealthy – one reason is due to delaying of medical care – because medical professionals do not treat overweight and obese patients with the objective care and respect they deserve. Here are some statistics:
In a study of 400 doctors:
• 1 out of 3 listed obesity as a condition to which they respond negatively, ranked behind only drug addiction, alcoholism, and mental illness.
• Obesity was associated with noncompliance, hostility, dishonesty,
& poor hygiene
• Self-report studies show that doctors view obese patients as lazy, lacking in self-control, non-compliant, unintelligent, weak-willed, and dishonest
• Psychologists ascribe more pathology, more negative and severe symptoms, and worse prognosis to obese patients compared to thinner patients presenting identical psychological profiles
In a survey of 2,449 overweight and obese women:
o 69%experienced bias from doctors
o 52% experienced recurring incidents of bias
In one survey of nurses:
o 31% said they would prefer not to care for obese patients
o 24% said that obese patients “repulsed them”
o 12% said they would prefer not to touch obese patients
It is for this reason that I am going to decline to continue coming to your office for my yearly exams. I will be patronizing fat-friendly medical offices in the future. If you have any questions for me about fat, size acceptance, or anything else of that nature, please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
Audrey
I’ll be adapting this into a short letter informing my NEW doctor about my weight and size acceptance; just to make sure that they are comfortable with the situation.
Meanwhile, I CRINGE at the thought of all the fat women my Gyno has shamed – I consider myself a strong woman, and well versed in size-acceptance – and I still caught myself being embarrassed about my size.
Then I got spittin’ mad about it.
If anyone can come up with a more polite way to say things in the letter, you are free to let me know – I am just STILL so angry (my appt was in mid-July), I don’t know any other way to put things. I have thought about thanking her for her previous services, but she fat-shamed me then, too – when I was SMALLER.(but by no means within the wt chart limits)
Any suggestions? Comments?
AGR, you know how I feel….the “medical” community has a LONG way to go when it comes to properly treating their fat patients.